Search blog.co.uk

What would I have done?

by Confuddled @ 2008-05-31 - 12:18:19

Have just spent a lazy morning reading the paper and drinking a large coffee. Whilst reading the "Review" section of the paper, came across a review of a new book "Their Darkest Hour: People Tested to the Extreme in World War Two" by Laurence Rees. The book, it would seem looks at both those who showed exceptionary bravery, and those who became, what could best be described as monsters.

Must admit, ever since I was a child, I've always had a morbid fascination about this subject. I could always be found in the War section at libraries or bookshops, perusing books that cover survivor stories or personal accounts. It's one of the main reasons I ended up studying History at University. What fascinates me is what is it about war that can make people committ horrendous acts? Besides those who actually committ the acts, there are also those who are aware of what is happening, but do nothing. And then there are the few, that are prepared to stand up and do something. But if you think about it, the majority of people don't. I don't wish to judge anyone and whenever I read the various accounts, I always find myself asking "what would I have done?"; "how would I have reacted?" I honestly don't know, or is it I don't want to know the answer to those questions?

I've just thought back to my childhood in South Africa, during which time, horrendous acts were being committed as well. OK, I was a child at the time, and it was only in my late teens that I became aware of some of the stuff that was going on. (Now I sound like I'm making excuses!) When I was old enough to vote, I voted for the "left wing" party rather than support the National Party. Went against my parents wishes by attending University of Cape Town - the first university to go multi-racial. But then I left the country. Whilst I was at University, I was too scared to take part in any mass demonstrations but many people did. So, does that mean even now, as an adult, I'd do things on the edges but ultimately be part of the majority that hope someone else would put a stop to it??

Quite a soul searching question isn't it? And, if you're really honest with yourself, would you be happy with your answer?

Think I'll be purchasing another book to add to my already bulging bookshelf.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

Cher2008Cher2008 [Member]
http://www.loonargifts.ca
2008-05-31 @ 12:34

Very interesting question. I know we'd like to think we would, but if that were really true then history would not have the majority not.

tylluanpenrytylluanpenry pro
2008-05-31 @ 12:45

The truth is, we don't know until the time comes. Most of the people I've known who say 'I'd have done such-and-such' are actually the last people you'd want with you in a crisis.

Most of us just hope we never have to find out....

ConfuddledConfuddled pro
2008-05-31 @ 15:09

As you say, the truth is until the crunch comes, we don't really know. So many times in those occassions, it is people we'd least expect that come to the fore and show amazing courage and bravery.

blacksheep63 [Visitor]

2008-05-31 @ 14:46

people do just tend to 'go with the flow' and take the easy option. interestingly this week the radio has been agitated about a woman who shopped her sons for wounding someone. they are now in prison as a result and her family has rejected her, not them. i think we have to stand and be counted, whatever happens to us. if we don't have convictions then i think we fail as human beings. in sartre's Age of Reason one of his characters, off to join fight franco in spain, says something like "no one can be a man until he has discovered something for which he is prepare to die". i read that at 17 and it still feels true nearly 30 years later.

ConfuddledConfuddled pro
2008-05-31 @ 15:15

Those are powerful words! I wonder how many of us have found what we'd be prepared to die for?
I heard about the story you're referred to and do think at times that society have a twisted sense of what's right.

timsuzitimsuzi pro
2008-06-05 @ 07:32

Sadly, most of us would fail the 'do the right thing in a crisis' question because the majority do stand by and watch. It is not just fear for our own selves that stop us acting but also fear of the consequences to the ones we love.

Found another quotation for you
The only thing needed for evil to prosper is for good men to do nothing.
Author: Edmund Burke

nearlyeddienearlyeddie [Member]
2008-06-14 @ 11:59

It's so interesting.

What divides those who can find the courage to stand up and take action and those who do not or who actually take part.

If only we could identify what it was that makes the difference! Given two individuals with similar backgrounds and circumstances.

It's such an amazing and complex "recipe" that makes up an individual isn't it? Genes, personality, beliefs and values, skills, resiliance, etc etc - too many elements which we will never succeed no matter how much we try, to understand completely!

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Recent Posts

  1. Wiki Meme
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-27
  2. Holiday
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-26
  3. What a month....!!!
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-21
  4. Anniversary
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-09
  5. Reflection time...
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-06
  6. Mostly You
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-05
  7. What is a True Friend?
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-02
  8. Time
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-09-01
  9. Adult & Dating
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-08-26
  10. South Coast
    by Confuddled pro on 2008-08-04

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.